Claim under audit
Loading…
Largest evidence units
Groups of papers the independence rubric treats as one source, with the reason.
| Unit | Papers | Strongest design | Why they count as one source |
|---|
Concentration across claims
Share of each claim's primary evidence that sits in its single largest unit. A high share means one group produced most of what exists.
Method
Design tier
Assigned from PubMed Publication Type and MeSH indexing by ordered rules in rubrics/design_tiers.v1.yaml. Papers PubMed hasn't indexed yet fall back to text rules and are drawn with a dashed outline.
Independence
Two papers are linked when they share a trial registry ID, a named cohort or a named trial, a lab anchor (first or last author plus two more shared authors), or at least half their authors. Authors are matched by OpenAlex ID where both papers are resolved. Rules live in rubrics/independence.v1.yaml. Linked papers form one unit.
Limits
Retrieval is one PubMed query, so the audit is only as good as the query. Merging is transitive, so large units deserve review. Live audits measure who produced the evidence and how; the findings layer (what each paper found) runs offline in the benchmarks.